People’s Historians Online: Abolitionists and Reconstruction

On July 10, the weekly People’s Historians Online mini-class featured a conversation with historian Manisha Sinha and high school teacher Adam Sanchez about the abolition movement and Reconstruction. The session addressed themes of our campaign to Teach Reconstruction.

Sinha stressed that the abolition movement should not be taught as a collection of individuals, but instead as a radical social movement. Here are just a few reflections from participants on what they learned. (More reflections at the end of this page.)

I learned about the magnitude of the abolition movement, which made me think more about how I’ve been taught it through the stories of a few huge figures. Another takeaway is that what is missing from subsequent social movements (post-Reconstruction) is a clear commitment to Black equality.

I need to show how large the abolition movement is. If I stress the involvement of many (including small towns, etc.), my students will be better able to see themselves in the movement and act today.

The large number of people involved in the abolition movement and their role before and after Civil War, including moving forward on schooling and economic equity after emancipation.

Highlights

Here are highlights of the session from the tweet thread by high school teacher and Zinn Education Project team member Ursula Wolfe-Rocca.

Video

Video of the full event, except the breakout sessions.

Resources

Books and Articles by Manisha Sinha

The Slave’s Cause: A History of Abolition

The Counterrevolution of Slavery: Politics and Ideology in Antebellum South Carolina

Civil War Revisionism Still Shames America via New York Daily News, May 4, 2017

First as Farce, Then as Tragedy via Jacobin, December 4, 2018

Freedom’s Unfinished Revolution: An Inquiry Into the Civil War and Reconstruction (Book) | Zinn Education Project: Teaching People's History Teaching a Peoples History of Abolition and the Civil War (Book Cover) | Zinn Education Project

Teaching Guides and Lessons

Who Fought to End Slavery? Meet the Abolitionists by Adam Sanchez, Brady Bennon, Deb Delman, and Jessica Lovaas

‘If There is No Struggle’: Teaching a People’s History of the Abolition Movement by Bill Bigelow

Poetry of Defiance: How the Enslaved Resisted by Adam Sanchez

When the Impossible Suddenly Became Possible: A Reconstruction Mixer by Adam Sanchez and Nqobile Mthethwa

Teaching a People’s History of Abolition and the Civil War edited by Adam Sanchez

SNCC: The New Abolitionists (Book) | Zinn Education Project: Teaching People's History Stamped from the Beginning The Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America book cover

More Books

The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America by Richard Rothstein

Ebony and Ivy: Race, Slavery, and the Troubled History of American Universities by Craig Wilder

The Fiery Trial: Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery by Eric Foner

The Second Founding: How the Civil War and Reconstruction Remade the Constitution by Eric Foner

SNCC: The New Abolitionists by Howard Zinn

Stamped from the Beginning:The Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America by Ibram Kendi

Stony the Road: Reconstruction, White Supremacy, and the Rise of Jim Crow by Henry Louis Gates

People

Margaret Garner also see Frances Harper’s poem on Margaret Garner

William Lloyd Garrison

Sarah and Angelina Grimke

Frances E. W. Harper

Theodore Parker

Maria Stewart

Mary Church Terrell

Sojourner Truth

Harriet Tubman

Phyllis Wheatley

Read more at Black Abolitionists profiles

Primary Sources, Digital Collections, and Projects

Black Land Project

SNCC Digital Gateway

Maria Stewart’s “An Address at the African Masonic Hall” speech (1833)

This Day in History

Sept. 28, 1829: An Appeal to the Coloured Citizens of the World

Nov. 25, 1859: Frances Ellen Watkins Harper Writes to John Brown in Prison

More This Day in History posts

Films and Performances

The Abolitionists PBS series

The Moment was Now A musical about Reconstruction, set in Baltimore.

Slave Catchers and Slave Resisters

Participant Reflections

Here are some of the responses by participants from the session evaluation.

What was learned

Responses to the question: What was the most important thing (story, idea) you learned today and what may you do with what you learned?

A crucially reinforced idea of abolition as a long, radical social movement, one with deep roots that trace back to pre-American Revolution (petitions) that endures to today, what Dr. Sinha or Adam referred to as the “current rebellion”. Banking on resonance of present day abolitionist movements (abolish prisons, abolish police, abolish schools, abolish racism in all its forms) to engage student curiosity about its long backstory.

I learned that the abolitionist movement was a large movement that spanned the country, not limited to a small radical group. Also, re-framing the idea that it wasn’t confined to a period but is a movement that is not finished! The resources are SO helpful for my history classes!

It was truly significant to learn about how instrumental Black women were in the abolitionist movement. I plan on bringing in narratives from abolitionists and the Reconstruction era into my ELA course.

Importance of Black abolitionists … I will focus on them for my teaching of U.S. history.

Affirmation! That Black struggle and liberation movements are at the center of all other liberation movements, from abolition in 1800s to today.

That enslaved people were a large part of the abolition movement.

The abolitionists movement was more widespread than what is presented in the textbooks

To continue to interrogate the racial ideas of everyone, here, more specifically of abolitionists. I will mention the Theodore Parker example as a way of saying “we are all — even dyed in the wool abolitionists — always, trying to purge ourselves of the inheritance of racial ideas.”

I learned more about the broader MOVEMENT of abolition — reminded me of Jeanne Theoharis’ comment about the “tendrils that lead up to a moment.” It was a good reminder not to stick to the same names that always get mentioned but to intentionally seek out the lesser known people involved in these movements.

I learned a LOT today! I appreciated the focus on African American abolitionists and the strategy/organizing/creativity of the movement! That Black abolitionists were establishing the basis for Reconstruction with emancipation leagues, etc. and also anticipating the problems of Reconstruction. The story of Parker was also really compelling/stands out as something I want to study in more depth. And I “met” Frances E. W. Parker! I can’t wait to read her work!

The history of abolition is a continuum that goes to the present! Some abolitionists have said they were “done” had achieved their goals at different points, and some (the more radical) keep going!

I’m inspired by thinking about how Black radical abolitionists laid the groundwork for Reconstruction. This idea presented by Dr. Sinha helps me consider cohesion to bridge antebellum America with Reconstruction in some really powerful ways. Also, centering female abolitionists remains an important thread to today’s Black Lives Matter movement.

Did not realize the size/scope of the movement. Will definitely re-frame teaching!

That the abolitionist movement was larger than discussed in most resources.

SO much to take back to my 5th graders! Distinction between antislavery and abolition movement; failure to center equality for BIPoC as Achilles heel of progressive movements; focusing on movements rather than individuals (pillar of white supremacy); pushback of Black abolitionists on white paternalism and meetings as opportunities for interracial debate, creative conflict, and growth — development of ideologies over time — model of Theodore Parker saying he was wrong!

Role of small abolitionist groups in many towns and the over all huge numbers of participants, especially as students grapple with what their role can be in our modern movements, reminding them that there is nothing unimportant in standing up for rights and what you believe in, small, big, local, national — all roles are important.

I also was reminded about how many individuals we know only the one quote from and learning more about their whole story rounds out their contributions and models how to fight for students.

Critiques of the PBS series The Abolitionists. I used to show it. If I do so again, I am better prepared to engage students in critiques of it.

The format

Loved listening and then being able to process in breakout groups and then come back.

Always wish these could be longer.

I love the format I have suggested it to many other groups that I have been working with.

I like the overall structure of the zoom.  I’d like more time in the small groups. We just got started when time ended.

The breakout rooms could use maybe 5 – 10 more minutes.

Wonderful presenter, the breakout group was great but too short. Our facilitator was fabulous. I think teachers are desperate for interaction with other teachers! The chat box is so distracting, especially when one participant, as happened today, is using bad faith arguments to comment on the presenter and purposefully misunderstanding the information being presented. I did not allow myself to reply, but I couldn’t focus as the comments continued to come in.

Fantastic format! Although I always wish for more time in the breakout room!

Format is great. Twelve minutes is too short in breakouts. Or maybe have two shorter breakouts — one for each question.

This was my first session with a small group facilitator and while all my other groups have had great discussions, it was nice to have a leader who so openly and kindly invited conversation.

The format of scholarly speaker in conversation with a classroom teacher facilitator really works well to focus the presenter’s amazing and vast knowledge and insights with questions that will come up in middle/high school curriculum planning. Having ideas about where to attach these new people and stories into my required curriculum is so helpful in planning how to pass on all the inspiring things I’m learning.

Everything, as usual, was wonderful! I have so appreciated these Friday sessions. They’ve really been a bright beacon of community and learning in this dark time.

Additional comments

Appreciate what you are doing to help us change the narrative regarding what is being taught in schools.

Thank you. This series has been incredible for me as a learner and a teacher.

Y’all are amazing. I appreciate your intellectual, emotional, spiritual labor with this work. Gratitude.

Thank you! I’m looking forward to going back to watch sessions I missed, and I hope there will be more.

I say this every week, I think. This opportunity every week has been so powerful for me as a learner, a teacher, and a person. You have created a space where the facts and the history support solidarity on a daily basis. I have been truly blessed and in some ways, carried through the last few months by the community that has gathered here. Deep thanks!

Thank you, thank you, thank you to all the presenters, leaders, facilitators and the Zinn Education Project team for making this series. It has been a highlight of the spring/summer and so helpful for keeping motivated and connected to amazing educators through this period of adapting to our new reality of distance learning.

I sincerely hope these webinars will continue. I have looked forward to these each week, and they have provided an incredible sense of community and purpose in these difficult times. Thank you to everyone involved for making these happen!

Manisha Sinha did an excellent job presenting the early and continuing history and components of abolition through the voices of abolitionists, both familiar and perhaps those relatively unknown. She also showed the parts some abolitionists played in their work, political and social, after slavery had ended, leading up to and including Reconstruction. Commentary from Adam Sanchez, as well as his sharing suggestions for further reading and other sources, was enlightening and inspirational. Having read some of his extensive writing, it was great to see and hear his views and input, as well.

Presenters

Manisha Sinha is the James L. and Shirley A. Draper Chair in American History at the University of Connecticut and a leading authority on the history of slavery and abolition and the Civil War and Reconstruction. She is the author of The Counterrevolution of Slavery: Politics and Ideology in Antebellum South Carolina and The Slave’s Cause: A History of Abolitionhas appeared on Democracy Now!; and is an advisor for the Zinn Education Project Teach Reconstruction campaign.

Adam Sanchez teaches at Abraham Lincoln High School in Philadelphia. He is a Rethinking Schools editor, a Zinn Education Project teacher leader, and is also editor of Teaching a People’s History of Abolition and the Civil War.

Share a story, question, or resource from your classroom.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *