From the beginning, Black men and women resisted their enslavement . . . under the most difficult conditions, under pain of mutilation and death, throughout their 200 years of enslavement in North America, these Afro-Americans continued to rebel. Only occasionally was there an organized insurrection. More often they showed their refusal to submit by running away. Even more often, they engaged in sabotage, slowdowns, and subtle forms of resistance which asserted, if only to themselves and their brothers and sisters, their dignity as human beings. — Howard Zinn, A People’s History of the United States
For too long, historians painted a picture of the idyllic old U.S. South with paternalistic slave owners and docile and content slaves. Though challenged in the 1930s and ’40s by historians like W. E. B. Du Bois and Herbert Aptheker, this remained the dominant narrative of slavery until the late 1960s and ’70s. Today, any discussion of slavery should be coupled with the myriad and heroic ways enslaved people resisted their enslavement.
It’s also important to put this resistance in the broader context of how the U.S. economy was built on the backs of enslaved people. Students should grapple with how central the labor, knowledge, and skills of enslaved people were to the entire Southern economy. The stakes for maintaining slavery were high and any resistance was often met with brutal retaliation.
Nevertheless, enslaved people, with great courage, engaged in all sorts of resistance. While this pre-Civil War resistance did not ultimately topple the deeply entrenched institution of slavery, it challenged pro-slavery arguments that enslaved people were happy and content and provided fuel for abolitionist denunciations of slavery. Maybe more importantly, it established a tradition of defiance that was built upon during the Civil War and Reconstruction when wider acts of resistance became possible.
This lesson introduces students to several of these concepts, establishes the various ways that enslaved people resisted, and celebrates that resistance, culminating in a collective poem. To write the poem, students will break into groups and each group will express in poetry what they’ve learned about resistance. This lesson provides seven types of resistance as a guide:
Group 1: Theft and Property Destruction
Group 2: Maintaining the Family
Group 3: Culture, Music, Religion, and Education
Group 4: Resistance at Work
Group 5: Running Away
Group 6: Verbal and Physical Confrontation
Group 7: Revolt
This lesson is published by Rethinking Schools in Teaching a People’s History of Abolition and the Civil War.
— MrsSchmittHistory (@BMSHistSchmitt) April 12, 2022
Middle School Social Studies Teacher, Washington, D.C.
Thank you, thank you, thank you for this powerful resource.
I started using Zinn Education Project teaching materials three years ago, particularly for the beginning of the year in my 8th grade U.S. history course.
Last year, I wanted my students to have a deeper understanding of the legacy of resistance before, during, and after the Civil War. So, I decided to teach the Poetry of Defiance lesson. I wanted to dismantle the idea that African Americans were bystanders in the fight against oppression.
The lesson was so well-received and sparked such great dialogue amongst my students that now I am attempting to use at least one Zinn Education Project lesson during every unit.
I used the lesson at the end of the school year. I remember how tired and emotionally exhausted my students were after almost a month of standardized testing, and yet when I taught this lesson they became so energized that they wanted to compile their poems to read to the class.
One student, who had not done extra projects before, offered to type up the poems during her lunch period. We displayed their work in the hallway on small boards and the students all came by to read the poetry of their peers. The words below of my students speak for themselves.
Write that I sang my sorrows away using that written word learned at night and worked not to my fullest capacity but moved slowly as the moon.
Write that we all enslaved people resisted slavery by coming up with our own plans to eventually rebel against our “slave masters.” We would pull down fences, sabotage farm equipment, break elements, and damage boats.
We gather as a whole with axes, clubs, knives to fight back, burn down crops, kill masters, freedom will come one day praying to god.
Write that I wouldn’t ignite the life of an enslaved person for revolt or punishment
Write that I witness children taken from the chest of women. Forced to work like males, only to give our fruits of our labor to our monster. Tired I was, when I got the plan, I made sure my master won’t get the fruit. I plowed and swallowed, and cracked the tool. When the whip came down, I knew it was worth it. The fruit of our work today was ours.
Write that I was bound with chains from the moment I ventured too far. Then thrust into a life of pain where I felt I was slowly sinking deeper into tar.
Write that we enslaved people were treated harshly and were being sold to many people. To the whites we were known as savages and animals.
Write that I have seen the brutal beatings performed by the slave owner to those of us they call their property. I have seen their attempts to silence our struggle. But we will rise.
Write that I saw my family run towards the freedom but blocked by violence but we did not give up and we never will.
Write that I write my spirituals, our thoughts we have spread to all that need it. Let our thoughts inspire others and let our words be a motive for them to do what they want.
Write that I needed no pass to get around, to ask a man and his power could I get around. Write that I walked outside the plantations with my free will and head high. Write that I no longer had that, as I walk along the fence in the plantations with dirty feet and low head.
Write that I will never be free knowing that I will still wake up every morning with hope. Write that through my life I have never known what freedom felt like, my only freedom would be my dreams or nightmares.
Write that I watched the light in my son’s eyes go out, write that I felt, the hot sun pushing me down, write that I waited but nothing… nobody came to save me.
Write that enslaved people were beaten day by day, nonstop work endless hours of doom.
Listening to the bold words of the enslaved outside, and the master’s whips going about. Tonight was gonna be a night of excitement, we were planning something big, so big that they wouldn’t know what hit them. Most run away or even asked for freedom, some had hidden messages in their religious singing. But we are using our ability to sabotage their workings. This will be amazing.
Adapting Adam Sanchez’s lesson, Poetry of Defiance: How the Enslaved Resisted, for online learning was a labor of love. The Rethinking Schools/Zinn Education Project’s mixer activities have been a catalyst for understanding in my classroom; I couldn’t imagine any space — even at a distance — that didn’t include that power.
The first hurdle to overcome was the difference in participation between a captive audience in class and students logging in when they can at home. There are the logistics of asynchronous participation which come from any online learning scenario. And there is particular care to be taken specifically during the COVID-19 outbreak, when families are experiencing stress and upheaval at home. . . . Continue reading
Before I taught Zinn Education Project lessons about resistance to enslavement, my students were under the impression the only types of agency enslaved people could exercise were running away or violent revolt. Some thought that if you didn’t run away or fight violently, then enslaved people must have accepted their condition of enslavement. The most popular or well known African Americans from this time period are Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglass, both of whom ran away. By the time students reach my class, these are often the only stories young students hear about resistance. It was time to set the record straight and expand their understanding of enslavement and resistance.
I chose the lesson Poetry of Defiance: How the Enslaved Resisted from the phenomenal teaching tool, Teaching a People’s History of Abolition and the Civil War. After learning about the variety of ways enslaved people resisted their enslavement, they came away with new understandings about how resistance exists on a continuum and that resistance can take many different forms as well as the fact that how a person chose to resist varied widely due to many different circumstances they faced. This has been one of my favorite lesson to teach from ZEP and I look forward to keeping it in permanent rotation when I teach about the lives of the enslaved. Thank you!
I have included a link to one of my student’s poems here.
I absolutely loved using the lesson plan, “Poetry of Defiance: How the Enslave Resisted.” My African American History students used the mixer activity to build background knowledge about leaders in the African American community during the period of U.S. slavery and how their expressions of agency differed in their resistance to being held in bondage. We talked as a class about the differences between passive and overt resistance and classified the tactics used by these leaders into those two categories.
From there, students used the examples of methods of resistance to write structured “Write That I” poems that used the power of repetitive language and structure to creatively express the struggles and grassroots pushbacks against slavery that were learned through the primary source experiences of enslaved persons utilizing methods of resistance. Students were able to make connections to acts of resistance in the face of adversity today as well. We displayed our poems in an exhibit box in the front of our school.