For two years, new education standards for history and social science classes have been drafted in a public process with the participation of educators, historians, geographers, economists, museum staff, diverse organizations, parents, students, and the Virginia Department of Education staff. They considered more than 6,000 public comments. This collaboration included the Commission on African American History Education.
As those new standards come up for formal adoption, the Virginia Department of Education under Gov. Glenn Youngkin has proposed their own revisions — in consultation with Hillsdale College, proponents of the right wing 1776 Curriculum. (Read more in Virginia education department proposes major changes to social studies standards by Joe Heim in The Washington Post.)
Two organizations working to defend teaching honestly about U.S. history, the Virginia Social Studies Leaders Consortium and the Hamkae Center, asked the Zinn Education Project to solicit comments on the proposed standards. We invited our colleagues at Historians for Peace and Democracy (H-PAD) to review them.
In addition, our staff member Mimi Eisen commented on the Reconstruction standards, drawing on the analysis in the report she co-authored, Erasing the Black Freedom Struggle: How State Standards Fail to Teach the Truth About Reconstruction. Those comments are below.
Gov. Youngkin’s draft standards on Reconstruction mark an egregious shift from the work that the Virginia Commission on African American History Education has been doing to provide a more accurate, just, and complete history. The Youngkin staff’s standards remove entirely, or broaden to a degree that renders them meaningless, key aspects of Reconstruction. They downplay African Americans’ aims and achievements for freedom and equality and the white backlash to those efforts, which are central to this history.
Here are a few examples, by course:
Virginia Studies (VS) course: The Commission’s standards highlight African Americans’ experiences contending with injustices and violence, as well as their pivotal work to found the state’s first public school system — among many other contributions and experiences. Youngkin’s staff erased these content areas or generalized them in ways that de-emphasize actual people and agency.
United States History: U.S. History 1865 to the Present (USII) course: The Commission’s standards highlight specific promises, intentions, and limitations embedded in the Reconstruction Amendments — which are foundational to many legal rights today. Youngkin’s standards remove most of this language and generalize the “goals and effects” of this and related Reconstruction-era legislation.
Virginia and United States History (VUS) course: Despite including a heading called “Expansion, Civil War, and Reconstruction,” Youngkin’s standards hardly address Reconstruction. This section lists dozens of standards; only a few belong to the Reconstruction era. These few standards are broad and minimizing, with an emphasis on white political leaders or passive voice with no actors. For example, they prompt students to explain the “extension of rights provided” in the Reconstruction Amendments, to describe the roles of “key” Civil War and Reconstruction figures such as Abraham Lincoln, Jefferson Davis, Ulysses S. Grant, and Robert E. Lee, and to evaluate and explain the “political and economic impact” of this period.
A true, complex accounting of Reconstruction reflected in social studies standards would center the myriad experiences, organizing efforts, and achievements of Black people for justice and multiracial democracy. And it should feature the many ways white supremacists mobilized to dismantle Reconstruction. With these new draft standards, Youngkin’s team joins a tradition of whitewashing and suppressing this history — to the detriment of students and communities across the state and beyond.
Add Your Voice
The Virginia Social Studies Leaders Consortium suggests these steps to add your voice of concern.
|Submit a letter to the Virginia Board of Education (VBOE) in opposition to the rewrite of the History and Social Science standards linked above. It is essential to note that the American Historical Association (AHA) urged the Virginia Board of Education to adopt the previous version of the proposed Social Studies Studies Standards that was the work of countless educators and historians over the course of the past two years according to the process detailed in Virginia Code.||
Please submit your letter to Emily Webb, Director for Board Relations firstname.lastname@example.org,
Please be sure to cc:
Governor Glenn Youngkin at Contact the Governor’s Office
Aimee Guidera, Secretary of Education at email@example.com
and your respective State Representatives
|We understand this is short notice, but this is critical. We need as many people as possible to sign-up to provide in-person public comment at the next Virginia Board of Education meeting on November 17, 2022 at the James Monroe Building in Richmond, Virginia.||
Requests to address the Board during the public comment portion of the meeting should be submitted to Megan Perez at firstname.lastname@example.org in advance of the meeting, but may be submitted the day of the meeting, at the discretion of the President. In honoring such requests, the Board will limit such comments to three minutes for each speaker at the discretion of the President.
*It is recommended that all who plan to speak also bring a hardcopy of their comments to leave with either Ms. Perez or Ms. Webb for their records.